A plan first floated in law review articles might actually come to fruition and make an end run around the Electoral College without abolishing it, says Brian J. Gaines, a professor of political science at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and the Honorable W. Russell Arrington Professor in State Politics at the U of I System’s Institute of Government and Public Affairs. Gaines spoke with News Bureau business and law editor Phil Ciciora about the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
What are the origins of the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, and how could it circumvent the Electoral College?
In 2007, Maryland kicked off a slow-moving, little-noticed move to nationalize the Electoral College. It passed a state law dictating that its electors would henceforth be awarded to the candidate winning the most votes nationwide — but only in the event that a sufficient number of other states joined this “interstate compact” such that members had a majority of the electoral votes. New Jersey, Illinois, Hawaii and Washington quickly followed, but by 2008, the movement was nowhere near the necessary 270 electoral votes for a majority. Nor, indeed, had they reached that magic number by 2024, even as the members list grew in fits and starts, and reapportionment of congressional seats and electoral votes trimmed the compact’s weight slightly in 2010 and 2020.
People are also reading…
As of today, 18 states and the District of Columbia are in on the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. Together, they have 222 electoral votes under the 2020 apportionment. A review of the roster suggests that the plan’s appeal has been one-sided in partisan terms. The members are uniformly blue, but not necessarily big or small, or high- or low-turnout states. Combing through the data on how those laws were passed confirms that it has almost been the case that Democrats rammed the plan through statehouses in the face of Republican opposition, in legislative chambers where donkeys outnumber elephants and over vetoes by GOP governors when necessary.
Not surprisingly, the blue tsunami of 2026 has proponents of the NPVIC salivating. Unexpectedly deep swings have given the Democratic Party unified control of state governments in nonmember states that have resisted the movement so far and are large enough that the 270 goal is in sight. Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, Wisconsin and Nevada have 61 electoral votes combined, which conceivably creates four distinct paths to a de facto popular vote presidential election.
How much traction does the movement have right now? Is it all but inevitable?
Absolutely not. There are at least five reasons not to pop the champagne corks just yet if you’re a presidential majoritarian.
First, even though most successful roll calls on joining the NPVIC have seen nearly straight party votes, having a Democratic majority is not sufficient to guarantee action. Many of the states now in on the plan first saw bills to join fail, even under unified Democratic control. Minnesota, for instance, joined in 2023, but had also had a Democratic trifecta in 2013-14. With a 73-61 edge in the House, Minnesota Democrats could not get a bill to join passed at that time.
Second, all of the states on the post-midterms wish list have seen NPVIC bills fail before, even in chambers with Democratic majorities. For example, Democrats controlled the Michigan House from 2007-10 and 2023-24. In 2008, they easily passed a bill to join the NPVIC in the House, but saw it die in the Republican-controlled Senate. In 2010 and 2023, NPVIC bills never even reached a floor vote. Unofficial results suggest that the Pennsylvania and Wisconsin state senates will have small Democratic margins, making near-total party unity critical.
Third, it might be harder, not easier, to get NPVIC bills passed now that the threshold is reachable. Prior votes were somewhat easy for state legislators, who knew that nothing would change immediately. The next roll calls will be more real and less symbolic.
Fourth, if all of those legislators line up and governors sign the NPVIC bills into law, the ink will still be wet when legal challenges follow. It remains hotly debated whether congressional approval is required of this particular compact under the “compact clause” of the Constitution. But congressional approval will be easy with Democrats in charge, right? The U.S. Senate is a less majoritarian institution than the U.S. House, and so even if it winds up 56-44, it is not a cinch that it would give NPVIC a green light, especially if a Republican prioritizes killing the change and filibusters the bill.
The fifth reason: There are many more wrinkles that might lead to protracted litigation. Consider that there is no official national popular vote. States certify results, and each NPVIC state has to add up the complete official votes, once they are reported, to choose its electors. Any ambiguity or delay in tabulation of final results in any state throws a wrench in the works. The state laws in place do not make clear how results from states using ranked-choice voting, which can produce multiple counts, should be added to the totals.
If the NPVIC were to go into effect, legal ambiguity about votes could be a genuine nightmare given the urgency of finalizing the presidential winner.
Doesn’t turning Texas blue effectively nullify the Electoral College?
Much depends on whether the 2026 blue wave was largely or almost entirely a rejection of Donald Trump and his policies, visited on his co-partisans because he was not on the ballot, or whether the nation is realigning, shifting left so that Democrats will once again be the natural majority party.
The 2028 election will not necessarily resolve this issue, as Trump will continue to provide the hordes of new Democratic incumbents a prominent foil for another couple of years. But my own guess is that the very deep swing we just saw has the potential to be short-lived if the GOP can emerge from Trump’s shadow, and particularly if the next presidential candidate represents a clean break from him. That is, the Republican candidate would have to be someone other than Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio or anyone else affiliated with the Trump administration.
Both parties have, in recent history, overreacted to good election results, only to see a quick reversal of fortune. Moreover, even as almost everyone assumes that the Electoral College is a boon to Republicans, its biases are subtle and can rapidly shift.
A simple test is to shift every state by the same few percentage points required to create a popular vote tie. In the presidential contests of 2004, 2008 and 2012, the Democratic candidates (John Kerry and Barack Obama) win these hypothetical contests. In 2020 and 2024, the imaginary tie favors the Republican candidate (Trump).
In short, if you’re someone whose only priority is maximizing the odds of a Democrat winning the presidency, then perhaps the appeal of the NPVIC is not as obvious as most assume.

